Sunday, February 23, 2025

Why Retail Loyalty Programs Are Failing – And How to Fix Them: Industry Expert

The traditional retail loyalty model is reaching a critical inflection point as evolving consumer expectations collide with economic pressures, creating an urgent need for innovative approaches, according to one of Canada’s leading loyalty strategists.

Lia Grimberg

“There’s pressure on consumer value from both ends. Customers are expecting more and they’re getting less. And that is a perfect storm for something needing to change,” says Lia Grimberg, Principal and Consultant at Radicle Loyalty, in an exclusive interview with 6ixRetail.

Recent data supports this observation. According to the 2025 Global Customer Loyalty Report from Antavo AI Loyalty Cloud, nearly 70% of consumers are actively seeking hard currency benefits – rewards, discounts, or cash back – from their loyalty programs. However, Grimberg notes that this creates a significant challenge for retailers struggling with compressed margins and increased financial scrutiny.

Redefining Value Beyond Points

PC Optimum Stamps (Image: Real Canadian Superstore)

While conventional wisdom might suggest doubling down on points-based rewards, Grimberg advocates for a more nuanced approach. “Think of things that are valuable to people outside of money that are effective and efficient to deliver to your members to solve a real tangible problem,” she explains, citing examples such as priority access, express checkout, or exclusive services.

This strategic pivot is already yielding results for some retailers. Grimberg points to PC Optimum’s recent innovation that successfully merged digital engagement with traditional loyalty mechanics. “They added yet another layer, which was gamification. It was promotional, it was limited time, and it was a stamp program… The promotion was highly, highly successful.”

The New Partnership Paradigm

Perhaps most intriguingly, Grimberg identifies a fundamental shift in how retailers approach loyalty partnerships. Recent unexpected collaborations – Expedia with Microsoft Bing, WestJet with Skip the Dishes, and Aeroplan with Bell – signal a move toward more experimental, shorter-term arrangements.

“I think we’re starting to get away from traditional marriages into some more unlikely kind of partnerships,” Grimberg observes. “The fact that you can try before you buy and you can date before you marry is probably not a bad thing as far as partnerships in loyalty are concerned.”

This shift toward flexible partnerships offers retailers a lower-risk way to test new markets and value propositions. However, Grimberg emphasizes that successful partnerships require careful evaluation of brand alignment, customer experience capabilities, and data-sharing protocols.

Overlooked Opportunities in Premium Demographics

While many retailers focus their loyalty efforts on younger consumers, Grimberg identifies significant untapped potential in the boomer market. “There’s not enough partnerships in the space of health and financial services and member-only travel catered to the 50-plus, 60-plus universe,” she notes, adding that this demographic often has both substantial assets and time to engage with well-designed programs.

Strategic Guidance for Retailers

Sephora Birthday Rewards at CF Toronto Eaton Centre (Image: 6ix Retail)

For retailers considering launching or revamping loyalty programs, Grimberg offers clear strategic direction: avoid direct competition with established programs like PC Optimum or Sephora Beauty Insider. Instead, she advocates for a focused approach that addresses specific customer needs and leverages unique brand assets.

“Don’t try to outplay them, play your own game,” she advises. “Think about what your customer needs, deliver against what that is, find a way to solve a problem for your target group.”

The Future of Loyalty

MEC Member Rewards (Toronto – HBC Eaton Centre) Image: 6ix Retail

Looking ahead, Grimberg sees a landscape where successful loyalty programs will be defined less by points accumulation and more by their ability to solve real customer problems. This might mean offering unique services, facilitating convenient experiences, or creating value through unexpected partnerships.

“It’s not about the system being broken,” Grimberg concludes, “but how we can continuously engage and provide more meaningful value to our customers through loyalty programs.”

For retailers navigating this evolving landscape, the message is clear: success in loyalty will come not from copying existing models, but from understanding and addressing specific customer needs in innovative ways. As economic pressures continue to reshape the retail environment, those who can deliver genuine value beyond traditional points-based rewards will be best positioned for success.

More from 6ix Retail

Steel N Ink Accelerates National Growth Strategy, Targets Premium Retail Centres and Tourist Destinations

Premium tattoo studio chain Steel N Ink expands across Canada's upscale retail centers and tourist markets, revolutionizing body art industry through strategic retail partnerships and demographic-driven growth

PHOTO REPORT: Yorkdale, Yonge Street, and Queen West (2/20/2025)

Retail Transitions Across Toronto: From Simons' Construction to T&T's Downtown Opening

Research Validates Urban Golf’s Entertainment-Driven Transformation

Study Shows 68% of Young Golfers Embrace Entertainment Venues as Urban Markets Lead Industry Evolution

Global Retail Report Spotlights Toronto’s Creative Retail Future

As international retailers push boundaries, Toronto's unique market characteristics create opportunities for innovative concepts

Sustainable Activewear Brand Orso Expands Toronto Footprint with Union Station Location

Canadian brand's second Toronto location marks strategic shift in competitive athleisure market

Harbour Sixty Unveils Landmark Transformation, Secures 25-Year Future in Toronto’s Dining Scene

Historic steakhouse expands to four levels, doubles workforce to 275+ employees with addition of modern Italian restaurant and premium event space

Mandy’s Announces Multi-City Expansion, Adding Yonge & Eglinton and Canary District to Toronto Portfolio

Fast-casual chain Mandy's Salads reveals next phase of national expansion, adding new locations in Toronto and Ottawa while growing Montreal presence

International Food Concepts Join Brookfield Place’s Expanding Retail Mix

Multiple first-to-market food concepts choose Brookfield Place Toronto for expansion, including Las Muns' North American debut and EAK Ramen's first Canadian location, as the downtown complex strengthens its dining and lifestyle offerings.

Kinton Ramen Expands GTA Footprint with Strategic Openings

Toronto-based ramen chain Kinton accelerates suburban expansion with new CF Markville location, marking significant growth from downtown roots to national presence under founder Chef Aki Urata's authentic vision

Shake Shack’s Yorkdale Opening Reimagines Mall Dining With Premium Concept

Shake Shack's 4,300-square-foot Yorkdale location introduces elevated dining concept beyond traditional food court, marking significant step in the Canadian expansion plan.

PHOTO REPORT: The Well, Queen Street West and More (2/8/2025)

A visual tour of retail changes across The Well, Queen West, and King Street, featuring new openings, closures, and developments shaping Toronto's downtown core.

Amazon MGM Studios Marks One Year in Toronto’s Port Lands, Celebrating Local Business Impact

One-year anniversary celebration highlights transformation of eastern waterfront into mixed-use entertainment and retail corridor

Supernatural Sets Sights on Yorkville for Flagship Wellness Location

Innovative wellness concept to introduce hyperbaric therapy and advanced biomarker testing in 4,300-square-foot space

Firehouse Subs Unveils Major GTA Expansion with Six New Locations Planned for 2025

Quick-service restaurant chain announces King East location, adapts store format for urban expansion while maintaining focus on community giving and local ownership

In Toronto’s Retail Evolution, Location Takes a Back Seat to Experience

Analysis of Toronto's transformed retail market reveals a complex ecosystem where omnichannel integration, flexible leasing, and community connections have become critical success factors beyond traditional location metrics.

Toronto Tourism Hits Record $8.8B: The Story Behind the Numbers

Despite fewer visitors than 2019, Toronto's tourism sector reached new heights with $8.8B in spending. Here's what's driving this shift toward high-value tourism and what it means for the city's future.

Toronto’s Historic Properties Lead Flexible Workspace Revolution, Reshaping Neighbourhood Economies

Historic Toronto properties are being transformed into flexible workspaces by IWG, creating economic catalysts that are revitalizing retail corridors and local communities.

Mid-Market Fashion’s Future: Innovation and Customer Connection Key to Survival, Says Retail Expert

Industry expert Evelyn Reynolds shares insights on how Canadian mid-market fashion retailers can thrive through customer-centric strategies and strategic innovation

Pür & Simple Marks 50th Location Milestone with New Bayview Village Flagship

Quebec-based Pür & Simple brings elevated breakfast experience to Bayview Village, marking 50th location with modern design concept and innovative menu offerings.

Cluck Clucks Maps Ambitious Growth Strategy Following Toronto Success

Toronto's Cluck Clucks reveals major expansion plans with three new Canadian restaurants, 16 planned Quebec locations, and its first U.S. outlet in Texas. CEO shares exclusive insights on growth strategy and tech innovation in quick-service restaurant sector.