Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Restaurant Loyalty Trumps Platform Preference: The Shifting Power Dynamic in Food Delivery

Toronto restaurants may have more leverage in the food delivery app ecosystem than previously recognized, according to new research from Field Agent Canada that challenges conventional wisdom about the relationship between restaurants and third-party delivery platforms.

Jeff Doucette

The findings, which show 60% of Canadians used at least one food delivery app in 2024, reveal that consumer loyalty lies primarily with restaurants rather than with specific delivery platforms.

“The general big takeaway is that there’s no real loyalty to a platform,” said Jeff Doucette, General Manager at Field Agent Canada, in an exclusive interview. “Most users have all three, or at least two apps. They really seem to be chasing their favorite restaurants and it has almost nothing to do with what is their favorite app.”

This insight represents what Doucette describes as an “aha moment” that could shift how restaurants approach their delivery strategy and negotiate with platforms like Uber Eats, Skip the Dishes, and DoorDash.

Field Agent’s research found that 62% of delivery app users utilized multiple platforms in 2024, with Uber Eats emerging as the market leader at 77% usage among app users. When forced to choose a preferred platform, 51% selected Uber Eats.

Image: Field Agent Canada

Despite these preferences, Doucette emphasized that consumers will readily switch between apps to access their preferred restaurants. “If my favorite restaurant is not on app X, then I will switch to app Y to follow my restaurant,” he noted, adding that this behavior challenges the narrative around fees that restaurants pay to the apps.

“It really challenges this whole idea about the fees that restaurants pay to the apps when the data that we’ve collected seems to say that if my favorite restaurant is not on app X, then I will switch to app Y,” Doucette said.

While delivery apps were gaining traction pre-pandemic, COVID-19 lockdowns dramatically accelerated consumer adoption and changed how Canadians think about foodservice.

“I think pandemic was definitely a booster. It changed the way that we think about food service,” Doucette explained. “I’m still somewhat shocked when I walk down my hallway at seven in the morning in my building and someone has had McDonald’s delivered to their home at seven a.m. on a Tuesday morning.”

Skip The Dishes Exclusive Window at Shake Shack Yonge Dundas (Image: 6ix Retail)

He noted that Canadians initially viewed ordering through delivery apps as a way to support restaurants during lockdowns, further cementing these platforms in consumer habits.

The research uncovered significant regional variations in delivery app usage, with Quebec leading at 70% adoption, while Atlantic Canada showed the lowest penetration at 46%. Ontario came in at the national average of approximately 60%.

Doucette attributed Quebec’s high adoption rate to several factors: “Quebec was locked down super hard. It was the worst of the restrictions for quite a while. And potentially that drove penetration. You also have Quebec being very much a food culture, a different sort of social context around food than the rest of Canada.”

These regional insights provide valuable market intelligence for both restaurants and delivery platforms looking to expand their presence in specific markets.

As delivery becomes a more significant revenue stream for restaurants—with some operators reporting 30-50% of revenue coming from delivery—restaurants are grappling with how to adapt their physical spaces and operations to accommodate this new reality.

“A delivery driver awaiting a pickup is a roadblock in your restaurant,” Doucette observed. “They’re standing somewhere, there isn’t a specific space for them. They’re just kind of there with their bag, looking out of place.”

More restaurants are now creating separate entrances and dedicated waiting areas for delivery, recognizing that the pickup experience affects service quality. “If you can make that experience better for delivery drivers, doesn’t that increase your downstream service to your end customer?” Doucette questioned.

While delivery apps present profitability challenges for restaurants due to fees, they also offer valuable discovery opportunities, particularly for independent restaurants that might otherwise struggle to reach a broader audience.

“It expands your universe beyond your neighborhood, beyond the streets that you’re used to,” Doucette said. “I don’t even know where it is on the map, but they’ll deliver to me for 99 cents. I’ll give it a try.”

Some restaurants are finding creative ways to maintain a direct connection with customers despite the intermediary nature of delivery apps. “Restaurants that I frequent through apps only because they’re sort of inconvenient for me to get to, they offer me in the bag—outside of the driver—a coupon for when you actually come into the restaurant,” Doucette shared.

Delivery Driver on Yonge Street (Image: 6ix Retail)

One critical area where restaurants are currently falling short is tracking the actual delivery experience after food leaves their establishment. According to Doucette, this represents a significant blind spot and opportunity for improvement.

“Restaurants lose the visibility of what that experience is like once the bag leaves their restaurant,” he explained. “It’s a huge area where food service companies should be investing in understanding the downstream experience and also using that information to hold the third-party apps accountable.”

The lack of a feedback loop between consumer complaints and restaurants creates what Doucette describes as a “black hole” in the customer experience journey.

Field Agent Canada supports foodservice operators with market intelligence services including operational insights, concept testing, and mystery shopping programs that help restaurants adapt to evolving consumer expectations.

More from 6ix Retail

EXCLUSIVE: Crunch Fitness Secures Landmark Financial District Location for Downtown Toronto Debut

Crunch Fitness signs 21,000-square-foot lease at 20 King West, transforming historic RBC gold vaults into premium PATH-connected gym targeting Gen Z demographic with fall 2025 opening.

Kitchen Hub Food Hall Coming Soon to Yorkville Village

Construction hoarding signals arrival of ghost kitchen pioneer at premium retail property

Wellington Market Completes 20,000 Sq. Ft. Expansion with Nine New Food Concepts

The Well development adds major retail brands KIT + ACE, Rodd & Gunn while Wellington Market exceeds 60,000 weekly visitors

KIT + ACE Relocates to Larger CF Toronto Eaton Centre Space After Strong Performance

CEO David Lui credits customer relationships and 18-month success for move to 4,100 sq ft former Williams Sonoma location

TTC Retail Store Motion: Matlow Reveals Strategy Behind Unanimous Board Vote

Exclusive interview: Councillor Josh Matlow explains the feasibility study parameters and revenue expectations behind the TTC Board's unanimous approval of his retail store motion.

Toronto Shoppers Lead ‘Buy Canadian’ Movement as 84% Embrace Local Retail Over U.S. Brands

New Lightspeed data reveals 84% of Toronto consumers are buying Canadian products over U.S. alternatives, with 79% wanting American goods removed from store shelves. Electronics retailers face biggest challenges while food and services lead opportunities.

Decathlon’s GTA Exit Opens Door for Experience-First Retail Revolution

Decathlon Canada closes five GTA stores in Brampton, Burlington, Markham, Scarborough and Vaughan, creating opportunities for experiential sporting goods retailers as Canadian market shifts toward community-focused retail.

Toronto Retailers Face Zero-Revenue Days as $1B Infrastructure Boom Tests Downtown Commercial Viability

Downtown Toronto retailers report complete revenue shutdowns during construction periods as the city's $1B infrastructure program creates unprecedented challenges for street-level businesses and property owners.

Financial District Restaurants Leverage Advanced Technology to Capture Return-to-Office Market

Lightspeed executive reveals how tableside technology and contactless systems are transforming Toronto's business dining landscape

TTC Board Approves Motion to Explore Physical Merchandise Store

Councillor Josh Matlow's motion directs staff to study brick-and-mortar TTC store feasibility by Q4 2025

The Five-Year Beverage Revolution: How FiiZ is Betting on Dirty Soda as Canada’s Next Big Thing

Adam Corrin has a theory about Canadian drinking habits—and it's about to reshape the beverage landscape from coast to coast.

Queen Street’s Dozy Shows How Local Manufacturing Powers Community Retail Success

Founder David Owen explains decade-long strategy of bridging traditional retail with online convenience in Toronto's Entertainment District

Chatime’s New Chapter: CEO Trinh Tham on Redefining Modern Asian Food & Beverage in Canada

Veteran retail executive outlines franchise optimization strategy and regional expansion plans for Canada's largest bubble tea network

Inside Steam Whistle’s Roundhouse Revival: How Community Engagement Drives Canadian Brewery Success

Toronto brewery leverages heritage location and production transparency to combat misconceptions while expanding retail footprint

Monte & Coe Opens First Physical Store in Toronto’s Distillery District

Canadian accessories brand launches year-long pop-up after decade of e-commerce success

STACKT Market Pioneers “Third Space” Retail Trend in Toronto

Shipping container marketplace demonstrates how community-focused retail concepts are reshaping traditional commerce models

Groove Wellness Transforms 1931 Heritage Building Into Community Hub on Yonge Street

Entrepreneur Sarah Abell opens 3,000-square-foot wellness concept at 2532 Yonge Street, targeting growing residential population in midtown corridor

Florin Restaurant Set to Anchor Financial District Revival at Victory Building

Turner Hospitality Group targets early June opening for heritage-focused Florentine trattoria

OCHE to Open First Canadian Location Above SPIN Toronto

DISTRIKT 461's founder discusses his partnership with the international gastro gaming brand, expansion plans, and navigating Toronto's competitive entertainment landscape

EB Games Doubles Down On In-Store Experiences And Employee Tech To Combat Digital Giants

Gaming retailer invests in flagship stores and technology to create advantage over competitors in the market and online.